Email marketing is often touted as one of the most effective ways of targeting consumers in the digital age, but how effective is it really? Here representatives of label, music magazine, and band weigh in on the value of email marketing in the music industry.
This summer, Dan Oshinsky, Director of Newsletters at Buzzfeed, penned a piece in which he argued that email marketing is now as important as ever. I found this interesting, and my own feelings somewhat conflicted, for two reasons:
Personally, I hate corporate update emails. I ignore them most of the time.
I do pay attention to emails from certain bands and labels. They work on me.
Here’s some context: I recently abandoned my email account and started an entirely new one because I was overwhelmed by the number of mailing lists I couldn’t seem to unsubscribe from, unsafe phishing emails, and spam. Starting over has helped me recognize which email marketing lists I missed being on and pinpoint which lists are working. Emails from bands like Direct Hit! and labels like Paper + Plastick Records always got through to me — I knew about upcoming releases and tour dates, and they rarely felt spammy. Since I play in several bands and have started to run a record label, myself, I’ve lately wondered if it was worth the time and effort to set up and start writing my own mailing list.
Naturally, I figured it was best to crowdsource the answer to this question, so I asked Vinnie Fiorello from Paper + Plastick, Tony Shrum from New Noise Magazine, and Nick Woods from Direct Hit! to give me some feedback. All three kindly obliged.
First, though, I want to look at some of the claims Oshinsky made in his article about email marketing and how I think it might relate (or not relate) to those of us involved in the music industry.
Oshinsky’s Points and Perspective
Oshinsky, early on in his think-piece, wrote that email is great for distribution, action, and unique voices. What he means is that sending out emails gives you direct access to a person to whom you might otherwise only have third-party access, and it works best when you’re able to make a clear ask of that person. He believes that, “when someone subscribes to your email list, they’re letting you into their inbox, and that’s a space reserved for family, friends, and maybe a handful of trusted newsletters or brands.”
When Oshinsky mentions “unique voices,” he tries to explain that emails should come from a distinct personality and not be written in complete marketing speak, because otherwise, the consumer has no chance of building a relationship with the marketer or brand.
Firstly, I want to point out that while I agree with the general concepts here regarding tone of voice, his “space reserved for… a handful of trusted newsletters or brands” idea doesn’t always hold up in reality. Unfortunately, you have to be extremely careful about what lists and apps you sign up for, because companies can sell your information to third parties; and malicious hacking spam bots are always on the prowl. Gmail’s Promotion, Social, and Primary inbox separators can help organize life for an oversubscribed person, but inbox privacy is much more complicated and nuanced then Oshinsky’s simplified statement.
Now obviously, the perspective of someone who works at Buzzfeed is a bit different than that of an independent musician. Buzzfeed tracks their analytics, seeing what emails generate clicks to find out what’s working. But in the music industry, website clicks aren’t as important to artists as album streams, merch sales, and concert ticket sales. So does email marketing help artists and labels to succeed in that fashion? Let’s find out!
I first heard Direct Hit! in 2010 on a split record with Mixtapes where they both played their own versions of the song “Werewolf Shame.” I loved it, so I went to their Bandcamp page to see if they had anything available for free. It was there that I signed up for their mailing list. It may have been a requirement to complete the download, but that was fine as the music was free and I figured I could always unsubscribe.
A year or two and thousands of neglected spam messages later, I saw a message in my inbox from their frontman Nick Woods about a new album and some tour dates. I realized that since I’d been on the band’s mailing list, they’d never sent anything that had felt like spam. Instead, they showed up to occasionally remind me Direct Hit! existed and was actively doing things. Given the band’s recent signing to Fat Wreck Chords and opening slots for Reel Big Fish, NOFX, and even Blink-182, I reached out to Nick to ask if he attributed any of this success to their mailing list.
“Definitely. If you can’t keep in touch with people who’ve tried your product before, it’s like starting over from scratch in building an audience every time you release a new one… The point of our email list has always been for retention/loyalty. New fans have always come about from new music and publicity.”
I asked if he also communicated with fans on an individual level through the mailing list and his response was affirmative. “There are thousands of bands, and making a personal connection helps to separate you from everyone else… [We started the mailing list] before [we started touring]. Originally it was just to make sure people who had already downloaded our [older] material were aware that we had new material available when we posted it.”
And look where they are now!
Direct Hit! is a band that is on the road touring and meeting new people every night. Not only are they actively marketing themselves via the internet, but they’re doing it in person alongside those efforts. That’s a benefit that companies running regular email lists don’t have. If you’re an artist, you need to recognize the unique opportunity you have as a performer — that you get to interact face-to-face with your fans, while your label does not. Sure, bands might take copies of a magazine to a show or have a label’s logo on the back of their records, but the personal relationship between the buyer and product are missing. Use that to your advantage. Ask fans at your shows to join your email list. Explain to them what sort of emails you send. Do as much as you can to connect your online and offline worlds, promoting your shows via your email list and your email list via your shows. The more often and more personally you talk to your fans — in person and in email — the stronger your fan relationships become.
Music Companies: Paper + Plastick Records and New Noise Magazine
Vinnie Fiorello behind the drums.
Paper + Plastick, a record label started in 2008 by Less Than Jake drummer Vinnie Fiorello, has two mailing lists. They have a marketing one that goes to customers and a digital music subscription list. In college, I was subscribed to the latter. By signing up, I received new MP3s weekly from bands like The Braces, Flatfoot 56, and Red City Radio before the albums had actually come out, and it was awesome! (Fiorello confirmed they still send out new songs once a week.)
However, when asked about whether a newsletter brings about any kind of sales boost, the results seem to be less notable. “[The Digital Subscription has brought] an increase in exposure, but not a lot of sales. You see an increase in traffic, but sales get a slight pop only.”
I asked about their general mailing list — the one sent to customers, and the sentiment was similar. “We see sales pop when [a marketing blast] goes out, but it’s not a sustained sales push.” However, he added that “it’s also not designed to be.”
Tony from New Noise Magazine shared a similar sentiment as to sales boosts from their weekly mailing list. “I send one out every Saturday recapping some stuff we posted that week,” he said. “It’s not the greatest source of sales or exposure, but I’ve noticed a little bump in both around the times the newsletters are released.”
An email list is one part of an overall sales strategy, but it isn’t the only thing that goes into promoting artists. It’s important to keep the conversation going, beyond a single monthly mass email, and make sure you’re connecting with fans across platforms and in a variety of ways that feel relevant to them.
“I think it helps more than it hurts” is the first thing Tony said to me when I asked him how worthwhile maintaining his mailing list is. And that’s the commonality between Direct Hit!’s experience as well as that of Paper + Plastick and New Noise. Mailing lists, when done right, can only help you. You may get a handful of unsubscribes each time you send a mailing, and it’s a lot of work to write, re-write, edit, and format these things, but all in all, emails contribute to an important dialogue you should be trying to create with your fanbase. So is it worth our time and effort?
Personally, I think it is, and will probably start one for my own label coming up here soon. The single most important thing for an artist to do with their marketing efforts is to keep the conversation going with their fans — to support and grow fans into the kinds of people who will come out to shows and buy albums. And it’s undeniable that email is one effective way to keep that conversation going. But it does have its limits, and it isn’t the only way you should be connecting with your fans. If you’re going to invest your time into a mailing list, keep it personal, and keep it relevant to your fans’ interests, and who knows, maybe six years from now, one of your fans will be writing an article about how much they’ve enjoyed your email list!
What have your experiences been with mailing lists for your band or brand? Let me know in the comments below or over on Twitter @Robolitious.
Learning Jazz gave me a masters degree in music. Jazz is American Classical Music, came
out of a need to be heard, to be understood, a voice when black America did not have one.
This is why the music is more than just an art form, it was created from blood, guts and heart
of those who suffered in this world. Its not to be taken lightly. If you do take it lightly it will
never sound right. Thank you to all the courageous musicians who made the world hear
them, their innovation came out of their experiences of the time that they lived. A treasure to
the world. American Classical Music. Imitate, Assimilate, Innovate a quote by Clark Terry.