Singer Judy Collins once said Ms. Stafford's poignant interpretation of folk ballads was pivotal to her own career in folk music. Although she made several acclaimed folk recordings, Ms. Stafford was mostly known as a pop vocalist with a warm, clean voice that music critic Terry Teachout called rhythmically fluid without ever sounding self-consciously 'jazzy.' From 1944 to 1954, Ms. Stafford placed nearly 75 songs in the pop charts as a solo entertainer. She was especially well-regarded for her versions of pop ballads including You Belong to Me," Make Love to Me," Autumn Leaves" and All the Things You Are."
A lifelong mischievous streak also led her to make cornball novelties of the day, from a mock hillbilly version of Temptation,," which she pronounced Tim-tayshun," to hits such as Shrimp Boats" and Jambalaya."
Although largely a solo artist, she recorded with singers Perry Como, Frankie Laine, Gordon MacRae, Johnny Mercer and Dick Haymes.