Not all Blue Note sessions are alikeeven though label owner-producer Alfred Lion favored a cookie-cutter approach that resulted in hundreds of hard-bop albums carrying a distinctive, muscular sound. Alto saxophonist Jackie McLean's first leadership date for Blue Note was Jackie's Baga stand-out album that consisted of two different sessions separated by almost two years. [Pictured above: Jackie McLean]
The first three tracks on the original album were recorded on January 18, 1959 while the second three were recorded on September 1, 1960. Two different groups were assembled by McLean for the dates, two different studios were used and two different political climates existed when they were recorded.
On the first session (Quadrangle, Blues Inn and Fidel), the musicians were Donald Byrd (tp), Jackie McLean (as), Sonny Clark (p), Paul Chambers (b) and Philly Joe Jones (d). On the second session (Appointment in Ghana, A Ballad for Doll and Isle of Java), the personnel changed: Blue Mitchell (tp), Jackie McLean (as), Tina Brooks (ts), Kenny Drew (p), Paul Chambers (b) and Art Taylor (d). All of the tracks were by McLean except Isle of Java. [Photo above of Sonny Clark by Francis Wolff]
Why wasn't the first band able to record all of the tracks on one or two sessions? Based on Tom Lord's Jazz Discography, it appears the quintet ran out of time on the first sessionwith the three songs requiring 3, 8 and 10 takes, respectively. Which doesn't mean much, since even more takes were required for the longer September 1 session, when a total of six songs were recorded. (The additional three were released only recently on CD.) [Pictured above: Jackie McLean]
So why was the first session so short? I did a little digging. It was held at Rudy's on a Sunday, which actually wasn't that unusual for Blue Note dates. Then I checked the weather. It turns out that a snow and ice storm had hit the New York area and temperatures plunged into the teens. My guess is the musicians either arrived late or they had to leave early to get back to the city in one piece.
A little history to put the two sessions in perspective: Fidel Castro had assumed power in Havana just 10 days before the first Jackie's Bag recording date. Though Fidel had been written by McLean earlier, the song clearly was used here as a tribute. Even though Cuba was Communist and an advisary by the second session, Fidel remained part of the late-'60 release. [Pictured above: Donald Byrd in a New York City subway car]
Another interesting aspect about the album: The first session was held at Rudy Van Gelder's Hackensack, N.J., studio [pictured above] and was among the last dates recorded there. By the spring of 1959, Rudy's new Englewood Cliffs, N.J., studio was completed, and Walter Davis Jr.'s Davis Cup became the first album recorded there on August 2, 1959. Interestingly, that first session also featured Byrd and McLean.
But what makes the two Jackie's Bag sessions especially interesting are the two pianistsSonny Clark and Kenny Drew. Clark's extended single-line solos (on Blues Inn, for example) are melodic and suspenseful, like the sound of someone hurrying home. Drew's solos are equally beautiful, though lusher and more of an exchange between his left and right hands (on Isle of Java, for instance).
Byrd is blistering on the 1959 date while Mitchell's improvised patterns are rounder and more colorful. And the addition of the red-hot Tina Brooks, who works both the upper and lower registers of his tenor sax here, seems to raise McLean's game on the second session. [Pictured above: Blue Mitchell]
As for McLean, between the two Jackie's Bag sessions, he appeared on several sessions, including Freddie Redd's monumental Music From the Connection and Lee Morgan's groovy Lee-Way. In 1959 and 1960, McLean was on fire.
JazzWax tracks: You'll find Jackie McLean's Jackie's Bag here.
JazzWax clip:Here's Jackie McLean and Donald Byrd on Quadrangle, which is based on I Got Rhythm's chord changes with a spray of Ornette Coleman's influence....